PowerShares to Close 19 ETFs

In another depressing development for the ETF industry, Invesco PowerShares Capital Management today announced plans to close 19 of its ETFs on May 18.

A random sampling of phone calls to industry insiders brought reactions ranging from “This is very bad news” to “It’s about time.”

“After carefully evaluating numerous factors including shareholder considerations, length of time on the market, asset levels and the potential for future growth, we proposed closing certain portfolios that have not gained sufficient acceptance with investors,” said Bruce Bond, president and CEO of Invesco PowerShares, in a written statement.

In the wake of the huge run up of 2006-2007, many industry insiders and industry watchers predicted a consolidation of funds. In didn’t take long for the process to start. Just two months into 2008 Claymore Securities shut down 11 ETFs. Since, then many independent ETF firms have eliminated funds, with some firms closing shop completely. However, PowerShares is definitely the largest ETF company to shut down funds and it’s shocking to see it joining this crew.

With 135 ETFs holding $25.8 billion in assets under management as of March 31, PowerShares was one of the four main ETF companies, along with State Street Global Advisors, iShares and Vanguard Group. According to the company, the affected funds represent less than 1% of PowerShares’ total assets.

Obviously, the industry made a decision in 2006 and 2007 to throw a lot of portfolio ideas against the wall to see what stuck. Some were offbeat, but interesting concepts. Some were just stupid. But, when investors feel flush they are willing to take a chance on interesting ideas. Of course, most people now eye investment products with suspicion and aren’t willing to trust Wall Street further than they can throw it.

Part of the problem is the overall economy and market conditions. Most investors are still shell shocked from seeing how the market’s crash decimated their nest eggs. They’re currently debating whether to pull their money out of the market completely or leave what’s left alone and hope for some bounceback. That’s assuming they still have a job. As more people lose their jobs, or worry about such, they are more likely to liquidate their investments than make new deposits. And the few that are willing to make new deposits are looking for the safest, most stable funds. Some of these ETFs probably could have survived in a more accepting market environment. But today investors sure don’t have any desire or patience to experiment with an offbeat portfolio idea like the PowerShares Dynamic Hardware & Consumer Electronics Portfolio (PHW), one of the funds due to close.

Here is the list of funds to close

* PowerShares Dynamic Aggressive Growth Portfolio (PGZ)
* PowerShares Dynamic Asia Pacific Portfolio (PUA)
*PowerShares Dynamic Deep Value Portfolio (PVM)
* PowerShares Dynamic Europe Portfolio (PEH)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI Asia Pacific ex-Japan Small-Mid Portfolio (PDQ)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI Basic Materials Sector Portfolio (PRFM)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI Consumer Goods Sector Portfolio (PRFG)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI Consumer Services Sector Portfolio (PRFS)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI Energy Sector Portfolio (PRFE)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI Europe Small-Mid Portfolio (PWD)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI Financials Sector Portfolio (PRFF)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI Health Care Sector Portfolio (PRFH)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI Industrials Sector Portfolio (PRFN)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI International Real Estate Portfolio (PRY)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI Telecommunications & Technology Sector Portfolio (PRFQ)
* PowerShares FTSE RAFI Utilities Sector Portfolio (PRFU)
* PowerShares High Growth Rate Dividend Achievers Portfolio (PHJ)
* PowerShares International Listed Private Equity Portfolio (PFP)

Personally, I’ll be sad to see the retirement of the ticker symbols PDQ, which I always thought of as Pretty Damn Quick, and PUA, the abbreviation for Pick-Up Artist.

Next week, the funds will begin the process of liquidating their respective portfolios. According to the press release, this process will cause each fund’s holdings to deviate from the securities included in its underlying index and each fund to increase its cash holdings, which may lead to increased tracking error. Shareholders may sell their holdings prior to May 19. Shareholders of record on the close of business May 18 will receive cash equal to the amount of the net asset value of their shares as of May 22, which will include any capital gains and dividends, in the cash portion of their brokerage accounts.


2 responses to “PowerShares to Close 19 ETFs

  1. Loke Kwok-kheong

    I read your book and am convinced that ETFs will suit me. This news of closing of 19 ETFs does dampen my enthusiasm but it should be O.K. if I confine myself to high volume ETFs in the US markets. Correct ? I am a stranger to US market. Looked into a few brokers’ websites. One charge .5% extra for 2000 shares on top of the per deal charge.

    • Thanks for reading the book. If a fund holding stocks or bonds is liquidated you money back, the current value of the underlying securities. So, you can take a risk on lower volume ETFs if you like the portfolio idea. I will take a look at the extra charge.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s